By Angela Lyles, Cornerstone
Revolutions, Inc.
Whether you're setting up a new investment advisory practice,
going solo after operating as part of a larger firm, expanding your
firm to include portfolio reporting or replacing your current system,
selection of software that is appropriate for the way you do business
is essential in providing you and your clients with the products and
services you can build your reputation upon.
Even before the first report is printed,
it's a necessity to explore numerous areas of product functionality
and output as well as gaining an understanding of the steps needed
to support the tasks your software will perform. If extra time is
spent up front in assessing the product and how it fits with your
firm's needs, the transition from getting started to full deployment
will be much easier.
Once the decision has been made to pursue
a PMS system for your practice, there are 4 primary areas to carefully
consider prior to purchase. These include product availability,
technology, functionality and services offered, which all work together
to complete the overall PMS package. Let's briefly explore each
of them:
Product Availability
& Access
Product use, access and pricing are important considerations in
choosing the right PMS solution for your practice. Some vendors
have certain limitations and/or restrictions over their offerings
and/or data methodology, so good questions to ask should include:
1. Are there any restraints or limitations
on how you access and/or retrieve your custodial data records?
2. Are there pricing differences depending on where you custody
your assets? If yes, could this be a conflict of interest for you?
3. Do you have full control over your data?
4. Does the vendor have any access or control over your data?
Pricing, particularly for small to mid sized
advisory offices, can also be a major component to the decision
making process. Carefully assess your list of functional and technical
requirements, and then separate the "have-to-have's" from
the "nice- to-have". Once you have prepared a punch list
of "must-have's", you will need to assess the costs involved
in order to meet these requirements and in the end, if it all makes
sense. Oftentimes advisors have a long laundry list of requirements
but sometimes the end the cost can outweigh the need. Items such
as network seats for simultaneous users, add-ons such as customized
reporting modules or custodial interfaces can also greatly contribute
to the cost of the initial purchase, so it's sometimes wise to start
slow and build as the practice grows, particularly if up-front costs
are an issue.
Ongoing maintenance fees and costs should
also be reviewed as part of the overall purchase. Vendors have wide
variances on their pricing models and it's recommended to compare
the initial purchase costs PLUS ongoing maintenance and add-on costs.
Spread sheeting these costs over a number of years, for example
a 5 (up to 10) year comparison, could be worthwhile in your cost
study and give you additional insights upon which your decision
can be made.
Once you have a narrowed-down list of vendors,
check with your custodians for potential affinity agreements for
those products. Oftentimes custodians have arrangements for product
discounts with various software vendors which could translate into
additional savings on your purchase.
Technology
Exploration and assessment of the data platform can be a key issue.
Is desktop vs. web based a consideration for you? And, does the
underlying technology offer compatibility with your needs such as
export functionality? Is import/export functionality an important
aspect to your practice so that underlying data can be utilized
in other applications?
You may be an advisor who feels strongly
about data ownership and (possibly) data portability, so the decision
to go with a desktop platform versus web-based could be critical
to your purchase decision. Desk top models offer a high degree of
data control, security and portability, and for some advisory clients,
a desktop solution may be viewed as a preferable alternative simply
from the perception of increased security offered by desktop solutions
as compared to client data storage via the web. Web based systems
usually offer "top down" administration of the transactional
data since data is held and manipulated on the vendor's servers.
Oftentimes data ownership is retained by the vendor and portability
can be a fee-for service, sometimes the data is format incompatible
with desktop platforms, or a (viable) data dump may not be available
for purchase at a later date should the user decide to discontinue
web service. Make detailed inquiries about these issues to determine
if the data platform, data export, ownership and security issues
are in sync with your needs.
Easy access to your data, particularly for
satellite office situations or the advisor who travels is another
important consideration. Web based solutions offer great user accessibility
irregardless of location -so satellite office and/or traveling scenarios
can be accommodated. Desktop platforms can also accommodate remote
access through such means as a vpn connection or specialty software
such as PCAnywhere, but the user may need to do some additional
setup work initially to establish the access for remote use.
Data extraction could be another factor
that is important for your practice. Extraction of client data for
use in other software applications may be desirable, possibly for
the purpose of customized reporting or portfolio analytics, as examples.
Define the specific data needed, how the platform will accommodate
the extraction process, and if the output format is compatible for
the use and systems desired.
Functionality
An in-depth functionality assessment is essential for your overall
satisfaction and long term use of the product by you and your team.
First, define the primary use of the tool
and how it relates to your practice. Will it be utilized as only
a reporting engine or will it be the centerpiece of your practice?
What other functions within the tool could your firm utilize now
or in the future? The following are some basic questions that you
may want to consider during your evaluation process:
Custodial interfaces
& integration with 3rd Party vendors
> Does the vendor offer linking to your primary custodian? Are
there other custodians that you deal with or may in the future,
and does the tool have linking to those?
> Does the tool offer other means through which various types
of data, such as transactions or pricing, can be imported into the
system?|
> Does the tool interface with other vendors, such as pricing
services or CRM systems?
> What is the process through which data is imported?
- Can imported data be easily manipulated?
- Can imported data be easily deleted and re-imported if needed
without fear of double-downloading?
Basic Functionality
> Is the user interface (the overall look/feel and use) of the
product "user-friendly"?
> Is there a free version of the product available for "test-driving"?
> How much ramp-up time will be needed to learn the new system?
- How complex is it? Is it intuitive or must a user manual be employed
to initially navigate the system?
- What type of training materials and service offerings are available
for new users?
- Could staff turnover be an issue, and if so, can the system be
learned quickly and easily by new hires?
> Does the system have any client contact information capabilities
such as telephone numbers, contacts, addresses, etc?
> Does the system support various matching methods that match
your needs?
> Does the system support trade-lot accounting?
> Does the system support account grouping?
> Can the user create "groups" of groups?
> Does the system offer corporate action functionality such as
spin-offs, merger/exchanges, ticker symbol changes?
Will the tool accommodate the types of
assets you manage and be supported in the reporting module?
> Do you need asset classing, industry groups or sectors, and
if so does the system support it?
- Can customized categories such as security types or asset classes
be created?
- Is there a limitation on the number of custom categories created?
> Do you require in-depth fixed income reporting?
> Do you need functionality for non-managed and/or illiquid assets
such as real estate or collectibles? How does the system make accommodations
for these items relative to reporting and pricing, for example?
Reporting
> What reports are a "must" for my practice and does
the tool offer them?
> Does the system support the return calculations you prefer?
- IRR, TWR, Modified Dietz, other
> Are comparative index returns and/or index blends supported
in the reporting module?
> Does the printing module offer various output options such
as .PDF or .xls?
> Does the module offer graphical reporting and is there an extra
cost associated for graphics?
> Does the system offer compliance related reports?
- Are the reports in the compliance suite, if offered, both useful
to your practice and sufficient to answer auditor's questions?
- Is there an extra charge for compliance reporting?
> Does the system offer batch printing capabilities?
> Are composite reporting options available?
Client Billing
> Does the system offer the flexibility required to accommodate
your billing style and formulas?
> Does it offer project billing?
> Tiered billing? Is there are limitation to the number of tiers
created?
> Fixed rate billing?
> Asset exclusion?
> Is billing supported at the single account level and/or available
for groups of accounts?
Asset Allocation
Modeling &/or Trading
> Does the system offer an asset allocation system that will
accommodate your specific investment style and rebalancing needs?
- Modeling capabilities at the security type, asset class, industry,
sector or individual security levels?
- Is modeling capability offered at the account level, on a group
of accounts, or both?
- Can the allocation include portions of other models or must it
be based on a single model?
- Does the rebalancing report meet your output requirements?
> Is there an extra charge for allocation modeling functionality?
> Is there a trading module component?
- Is there an extra charge for the trading "platform"?
- Does the platform include trade upload, execution and/or matching?
- Does the platform include creation of trade tickets?
- Is there functionality for security exclusion and/or constraints?
- Is there a component for client Investment Policy Statements?
- How does the system account for/accommodate cash, or cash shortages,
when rebalancing and trade execution is desired.
Services
There are numerous components to vendor service packages that should
be explored prior to making a final purchase decision. Items for
consideration can include customer service offerings, staff training
services and available training materials, data conversion services
and back office service offerings.
First, what types of training materials
are available for you and your staff? Are there tutorials available?
Can one-on-one training be purchased, and if so at what cost? Does
the product come with training manuals, is the product help documentation
easily understandable and sufficient to meet your needs, and are
free user training sessions such as webinars available for viewing?
Second, what is the vendor's overall reputation
for providing customer centric service? If you call for help how
long will you be placed on hold and will you reach a live person?
Will you be treated politely and as a valued client, and is the
expertise provided sufficient to answer your issue? What methods
of service are offered such as support via email, telephone or fax
and what are the typical response times, and what support packages
are available for purchase and will they meet your needs?
Next, define your plan for populating your
initial database. Who will be responsible for setting up the system
and importing data into it? Does your staff have the training, skill
and orientation to accurately and completely handle the initial
setup? Check with your vendor to see if they offer services to assist
you with the initial system setup and the cost associated with the
service.
Finally, if data migration is desired or
required, there is much to be explored before embarking on such
a project. Pricing and services for data migration vary widely between
vendors so all offerings must be carefully assessed and compared.
Determine the list of items that will be converted such as account
activity, pricing, security information, billing formulas, etc and
compare each offering for items included vs. items that are excluded
or that l involve additional costs. Keep in mind that depending
on the amount of data to be converted, data conversion is typically
expensive, time consuming, and difficult. Oftentimes projects require
significant time commitments by both parties and much collaboration
between the advisory firm and the vendor is required in order to
achieve the desired results. Key components in the final decision
(and pricing of the project) will directly tie to the amount of
history that must be migrated, the overall condition of the underlying
data (have all accounts been reconciled consistently and accurately?),
and if there are any date gaps of transactional, pricing and/or
reconciliation data.
Purchasing and deploying a PMS system can be one of the most important
decisions made by an advisory firm. Because deployment of these
tools can be expensive, time consuming and oftentimes painful, careful
assessment prior to purchase is highly recommended. Performing due-diligence
early on will help insure your overall product satisfaction and
use of the tool over the long-term.
|